Art or Graffiti? What’s Your Take?

There’s a wall in Port Elizabeth Central that most people have passed a hundred times without really seeing. For years, it was just noise — layers of tags, half-finished scrawls, the kind of surface the eye slides off without registering. Then, one day, it wasn’t. Somebody picked up a brush instead of a can, and the noise became a picture. Same wall. Same city. A completely different reaction from everyone who walked past it.

So, what actually separates “graffiti” from “art”? Is it the image itself — or is it who gave permission for it to be there?

Port Elizabeth has lived this exact story before. Back in 2013, a group of local artists — Nathan Sanan, Steven Carter, Paolo Maneli and Quintin Weyer — approached the developers behind the Something Good roadhouse overlooking Pollok Beach with an idea: take a wall that had become a magnet for graffiti, and turn it into a proper mural. Sanan, an architect by trade, said the goal was simple — to share their love of urban art and “instil a sense of pride” in residents, using colour and craft to push back against the tagging that had taken over the space.

What stands out in that story isn’t really the mural itself. It’s the admission buried inside it: the wall was already a canvas. People were already using it to say something. The artists didn’t introduce art to a blank space — they replaced one form of expression with another, one the city was willing to call legitimate.

A few streets over, Central has its official answer to that question, unmissable and fully sanctioned: Route 67, the public art trail that winds up toward the Donkin Reserve through 67 individual works — murals, mosaics, sculpture — each one marking a year of Nelson Mandela’s public life. The Bus Station Mural alone, painted by the collective 4 Blind Mice, was designed specifically to celebrate the everyday commuters who pass through it. It’s vivid, civic-minded, and it was commissioned by the Mandela Bay Development Agency on behalf of the municipality.

This mural by 4 Blind Mice is a carefully constructed design that celebrates public transport and the daily journeys undertaken by the people of Port Elizabeth. Source: Graffiti in Port Elizabeth

Nobody debates whether Route 67 is “art.” It has a plaque. It has a budget line. It has permission. And that is arguably the actual dividing line in most people’s minds — not talent, not colour, not even permanence. Permission. The same aerosol can, the same wall, the same skill with a spray nozzle can be called vandalism or heritage depending entirely on whether someone in an office signed off on it first. Here’s the part more interesting than the semantics: how many people actually stop for any of it anymore?

MBDA’s Route 67 consists of 67 Public Art Works symbolising Nelson Mandela’s 67 years of work dedicated to the Freedom of South Africa 

Route 67 was built to be walked slowly — to draw a pause at the Voting Line sculpture, an exchanged word with a stranger, a moment to listen for the Campanile’s bells. But most of Central moves past its own art at commuter speed. People will queue for a gallery opening and not glance twice at a mural they drive past every single day. Somewhere along the way, “art” became something you go and see, on purpose, in a building designed for the purpose — and everything else became scenery.

Maybe that’s the real question hiding behind “art or graffiti.” It isn’t really about definitions. It’s about attention. A tag gets read as vandalism partly because no one was invited to slow down and look at it. A mural gets read as art partly because someone put a frame around the moment — a plaque, a launch event, a story in the newspaper — and declared it worth a second look.

Painting in Norwich, Gqeberha

Looking at the paintings in Central, the point isn’t to settle on a label before looking closely. It’s what happens in the half-second before that decision gets made. Is it intention, or intrusion? Craft, or clutter? And if the answer changes once the question of permission comes up — what does that say about what “art” actually means?

Because if Port Elizabeth’s own walls can flip from vandalism to civic pride with nothing but a fresh coat of paint and a press release, maybe the line was never about the image at all.

What’s your take?

Renewing the Friendly City through Peace: Nelson Mandela Bay Unites Against Violence

Gqeberha, South Africa – November 15, 2025 –Community members from Nelson Mandela Bay gathered at the Walmer Town Hall for the final regional event commemorating the 11th Anniversary of the September 18th HWPL World Peace Summit. Hosted by the international peace NGO, HWPL, in collaboration with the IWPG and the IPYG, the event was held under the theme: “Renewing the Friendly City through Peace: Uniting Together to End Gun Violence, GBV, and Drug Abuse.”

The event took place against the backdrop of ongoing concerns in South Africa related to gender-based violence, crime, and substance abuse. Leaders from civic structures, faith communities, the youth sector, and women’s organisations spoke about the urgent need to revive a culture of empathy, respect, and accountability. They emphasised that peace is not only a global ideal but a local responsibility that starts in homes, schools, and neighbourhoods.

MMC Mkhuseli Jack urged residents to take an active role in reporting criminal activity, noting its impact on public safety resources. “We must not be quiet when we see crime taking place. We must report it to the police. When we don’t report, it affects the amount of money the government can give to the police budget to fight crime.” His statement highlighted the direct link between community involvement and stronger institutional support for safety, underlining that silence only strengthens the cycle of violence.

Member of the Mayoral Committee, Councillor Mkhuseli Jack, speaking during the HPWL event

The event showcased peace education as a vital preventative tool, demonstrating how teaching empathy, conflict resolution, and non-violence can transform the mind-set of future generations. Interfaith leaders offered reflections that highlighted unity across belief systems, while youth and women shared peace pledges emphasising the sanctity of life and the protection of the vulnerable.

The collaboration between global peace movements and local community actors created an environment that reflected both the aspirations and the challenges present in Nelson Mandela Bay. The event also took place against the backdrop of national discussions related to the upcoming Women for Change mobilisation linked to the G20 Summit. The event reinforced the shared conviction that South Africa needs long-term, preventative solutions that address the root of violence. Peace education, community cooperation, and consistent advocacy were highlighted as essential components in efforts to strengthen safety for women and children.

The event concluded with participants expressing willingness to continue collaboration. Organizers stated that continued partnerships and community engagement will remain important as Nelson Mandela Bay works to strengthen safety and social cohesion.

For media inquiries or collaboration opportunities, please contact: press_za@hwpl.kr | +27 76 963 7925